Is Hawthorn Football Club the best club ever?

I was just wondering as i am a long time Hawthorn fan!!!!


Go Sam Mitchell!!:D

Is Hawthorn Football Club the best club ever?
Half you fools can't even spell. How can we expect to take your opinions seriously. Gosh, learn some grammar guys!





Hawthorn is not the best ever. But we might just see what they really are come season's end. Essendon and Carlton (although they pretty much suck now) have the most premiership flags so based on that, they would be the best.





After all, a club's main objective is to win a premiership. Therefore wouldn't the club/s with the most be considered the best?
Reply:your just wondering are you?





No, they are not the best side ever, if they win 3 or 4 flags in a row, get back to me.





At this point in time the present side has done nothing, grand final wins are what the clubs play for and are judged by, as i said, at present Hawthorne have done nothing yet!
Reply:For you Tessa unfortunately no, they are a very good and proud club, no doubt about it but if you have to got to records Essendon, Carlton and Collingwood would be the top 3 overall. But the Hawks aren't far off though with the tigers, Dees and maybe Fitsroy/Brisbane.





P.S can you please answer my question on Robert Walls. Thank you Tes.
Reply:yeah have been for a while..Well since back in the "good old days' of Jasin Dunstall,Dermott Breraton,John Platten, The Big Dipper and even the old fart Micheal Tuck...Yeah they have hard a lot of hard years since the 80's but i think it is all about to turn around for the Hawkers....
Reply:Im a rabid Hawk fan but I have to say no...going back over the years clubs like Collingwood and Melbourne stand out as do Carlton and Richmond. But since 1980 they would have to rate as one of the best of the modern era, along with Brisbane and West Coast.
Reply:No. The ACT Brumbies are the best club in Australia
Reply:i love the hawks but no not yet they will be soon go the hawks